Ocean Bay Park
Fire Island NY

Ocean Bay Park Fire Island NYOcean Bay Park Fire Island NYOcean Bay Park Fire Island NY

Ocean Bay Park
Fire Island NY

Ocean Bay Park Fire Island NYOcean Bay Park Fire Island NYOcean Bay Park Fire Island NY
  • Home
  • About
  • Listings
  • Contact
  • FAIR HOUSING NOTICE
  • More
    • Home
    • About
    • Listings
    • Contact
    • FAIR HOUSING NOTICE

  • Home
  • About
  • Listings
  • Contact
  • FAIR HOUSING NOTICE

Homes for Sale in Ocean Bay Park

37 Traffic Ave

Oceanfront Retreat

Oceanfront Retreat

$4,500,000

MLS# 977357

By Appointment ONLY

Oceanfront Retreat

Oceanfront Retreat

Oceanfront Retreat

MLS# 977357 

Rooms: 13

Bedrooms: 5

Bath Full: 2

Bath Half: 1

Outdoor Shower: 1 

Property Highlights

Oceanfront Retreat

Year Built: 2011

Year Built Decks & Pool: 2024

School District: Fire Island 

Property Size: 67x100

Taxes: $8,977

Flood Insurance: $935

Total SQFT: 3,700

# of Floors: 2

# of Decks: 3

Roof Deck: Y

Terrace: Y

Pool: 19'x12'

A/C: Central Air 

Heat: Elec

Oceanfront: Y

20 Seneca St

$1,385,000

MLS# 906137

By Appointment ONLY

Beach House

MLS# 906137

Rooms: 9

Bedrooms: 4

Bath Full: 1

Bath Half: 1

Outdoor Shower: 1 

Property Highlights

Year Built: 1970

Year Built Decks: 2025

School District: Fire Island 

Property Size: 50x100

Taxes: $4,845

Flood Insurance: $1,273

Total SQFT: 1,870

# of Floors: 2

# of Decks: 1

Roof Deck: N

Terrace: N

Pool: N

A/C: Central Air 

Heat: Elec

Oceanfront: N

Joy Tosini, Listing Broker

Joy Tosini, Listing Broker

Joy Tosini, Listing Broker

Showing Instructions: BY APPOINTMENT 

Scheduling: Email: joy@joytosini.com  Text: 833.678.6780

 

Gallery of 37 Traffic Ave

    Gallery of 20 Seneca St

      Copyright © 2026 Ocean Bay Park Properties - All Rights Reserved.

      Powered by

      • Home
      • FAIR HOUSING NOTICE

      This website uses cookies.

      We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

      Accept